Tender and buttery vanilla thumbprint cookies with a semi-sweet creamy chocolate ganache filling. An easy cookie recipe that’s perfect for holiday parties or when you want something a little more sophisticated than a chocolate chip cookie.
Tip: this step goes faster if you use room-temperature butter.
![]()
![]()
Tip: There will be a stage where it looks like cottage cheese – this is normal! Scrape down the bowl and keep going. It will come together, I promise.
![]()
![]()
Tip: if using a rounded teaspoon, wipe off the back with a clean towel every four cookies or so to help the process go smoothly.![]()
Tip: The cookies are done when they’ve spread slightly, they no longer look wet or have a shine to them, and the edges are just starting to turn golden.
Tip: do not step away from the stove as the cream should reach temperature rather quickly, and dairy can quickly get out of control if left unattended on the stove.
Tip: if your ganache breaks (starts to look grainy or oily), add a teaspoon of hot water and vigorously whisk into your ganache until it starts to come back together. If it doesn’t start to re-emulsify, add another teaspoon of hot water and repeat.![]()
![]()
Store covered at room temperature for up to three days, or about a week if covered in the fridge.
Check out the blog post for this recipe if you’re looking for ideas to use any leftover ganache!
*If you aren’t measuring your flour by weight, the most consistent way to measure your flour is to stir the flour in the bag/container with a spoon to break up any dense clumps, then spoon the flour into your measuring cup and level it off with the handle of your spoon or the spine of a knife.
Dairy
Pantry